Best Seafood Restaurants on Hatteras Island

What would a trip to the sea be without delicious seafood? Hatteras Island's maritime history is rich and includes local and commercial fishing. Fresh-caught seafood is brought in every day so why miss out on a chance to taste some of the best seafood on the coast? Hatteras Island is full of incredible seafood restaurants to satisfy any craving. 

Whether you like fish, crabs, lobster, or oysters, you'll find it all here on Hatteras Island. Browse through the best seafood restaurants on Hatteras Island and start planning your tasting tour today! 

1. Breakwater Restaurant

Overlooking the Pamlico Sound, Breakwater offers a tranquil ambiance that perfectly complements its casual but delicious seafood menu. Imagine feasting on freshly caught seafood all while enjoying the picturesque views of Pamlico Sound and boats coming and going. They offer "something for everyone" including pastas and a full drink menu of wines, beer, and cocktails!

2. Dinky's Waterfront Restaurant

At Dinky's, it's not just about the food; it's about the experience. Situated in Hatteras Village, this gem offers panoramic views of the marina. With a diverse seafood menu and daily specials, you're sure to find something you love. Make sure you check out their Facebook page for daily updates on their specials! Don’t forget to try their unique chowders, gumbos, and bisques – a local favorite that warms the soul!

3. Tavern on 12

Located in Frisco, Tavern on 12 is perfect for those looking for delicious, fresh seafood and other offerings for someone that might not have nautical tastebuds. Their wide-ranging menu offers American fare of all kinds plus the seafood that you crave when you're near the ocean. They have a full-service bar as well so get something cold to help you gulp down your fried flounder.  

4. Harbor House Seafood Market

Harbor House Seafood Market is perfect for large groups or those who want to enjoy their food from the comfort of their vacation rental. More than just a restaurant, this seafood market lets you select your fresh catch and they'll prepare it to perfection. Whether it's jumbo crab legs or steamed shrimp, Harbor House offers a hands-on experience that’s both fun and flavorsome. You'll get to take your order, no matter how large or small, back to your vacation rental and enjoy your seafood bounty with your loved ones!

5. Rusty's Surf & Turf

What goes great with seafood? Steak, of course! Blending coastal cuisine with global flavors, Rusty's Surf & Turf offers an innovative menu that stays true to coastal NC while introducing some Asian influence into the recipes. Dive into their Kahuku Shrimp or enjoy the richness of their Kalbi Steak. You'll get a blast of flavor and freshness with every bite! 

Take a Seafood Tour and Book Your Hatteras Island Vacation Rental Today!

Brindley Beach offers a range of vacation rentals, from cozy cottages for couples to spacious homes for families and groups. Imagine waking up to the sound of crashing waves and the scent of salty air, all from the comfort of your own beachfront vacation rental. You'll have a fully-equipped kitchen and many homes come with a grill so you can also cook up some delicious local seafood yourself during your stay! Browse through our available properties and book your stay today!